• Study here
    • Study here
    • Undergraduates
    • Graduates
    • Visiting students
    • Outreach with schools and colleges
  • Living here
    • Living here
    • Where you will live
    • Eating here
    • Library & resources
    • Chapel & Faith
    • Do what you love
    • Help is on hand
  • Our people
  • News, events and more
    • News, events and more
    • Our vision for 2030
    • News
    • Events
    • Hertford history
    • Rare books & Archives
    • International Programmes
    • Conferences & events
    • Governance & legal
    • Vacancies
    • Visit us
    • Contact us
  • Hertford Intranet
  • International Programmes
    • International Programmes
    • Directors’ welcome
    • Our programmes
    • Our partnerships
    • Life in Oxford
    • Hertford in Asia
    • How to apply
  • Alumni
    • Alumni
    • Hertford today
    • Meet the Hertfordians
    • Publications
    • Alumni societies
    • Alumni FAQs
    • Update your details
    • Meet the Development team
  • Support us
    • Support us
    • Give to Hertford
    • Fundraising priorities
    • Leave a legacy
    • For donors
  • Contact us
xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">
  • Hertford Intranet
  • International Programmes
    • International Programmes
    • Directors’ welcome
    • Our programmes
    • Our partnerships
    • Life in Oxford
    • Hertford in Asia
    • How to apply
  • Alumni
    • Alumni
    • Hertford today
    • Meet the Hertfordians
    • Publications
    • Alumni societies
    • Alumni FAQs
    • Update your details
    • Meet the Development team
  • Support us
    • Support us
    • Give to Hertford
    • Fundraising priorities
    • Leave a legacy
    • For donors
  • Contact us
  • Study here
  • Living here
  • Our people
  • News, events and more

Study here  ›

  • Undergraduates
  • Graduates
  • Visiting students
  • Outreach with schools and colleges

Living here  ›

  • Where you will live
  • Eating here
  • Library & resources
  • Chapel & Faith
  • Do what you love
  • Help is on hand

News, events and more  ›

  • Our vision for 2030
  • News
  • Events
  • Hertford history
  • Rare books & Archives
  • International Programmes
  • Conferences & events
  • Governance & legal
  • Vacancies
  • Visit us
  • Contact us
Home / Alumni / Publications / Hertford Blog / The Truth About the Housing Crisis

The Truth About the Housing Crisis

J P Lusk (PPE, 1966)

We all know about the UK’s ‘housing crisis’ and its result: owner-occupation is increasingly out of reach of the young, so rising generations rely on private rental. More than one household in five now rents privately, with a mean age of 40, compared with a mean age of 57 among owner-occupiers. More and more young working parents rely on one-year rental contracts to secure a home in which to raise a family. They are in the ‘squeezed middle’: the poorer may access social housing, the richer home ownership, those in the middle go into the private rented sector.

The usual explanation for the problem is a ‘shortage’ of housing, so the solution is to build more homes, and the planning system is blamed for restricting this. But this is plainly wrong. When I came up to Hertford in the mid-1960s, Great Britain had 16.5 million dwellings and a population of 51.3 million – one home for every 3.1 people. Fifty years later there were nearly 28 million dwellings for a population of 64 million – one home for every 2.3 people. During the same period, house prices grew from around three times mean annual earnings to around seven times that figure. The plain fact is that net growth in the housing stock greatly exceeded the growth of population in this period, but prices more than doubled in terms of real affordability for a working-age buyer.

Why? Doesn’t this defy the iron law of economics – that price is determined by supply and demand? The problem here is a common confusion of housing stock with housing supply. The supply of housing for a purchaser in the market is not the total stock: it is the portion being offered by sellers. Roughly 5% of the stock is available at any time for sale or rent – and much of this is offered by people who wish to move and so are both sellers and buyers in the market. New buyers without these assets – notably the young – are bidding for just a tiny fraction of the total housing stock.

What about the rest of the stock? A little over 60% is owner-occupied, mostly by people who bought when prices were far below what they are today. More than half are now debt-free. Owner occupiers who have a mortgage pay half what renters do for housing, expressed as a proportion of their income.  So, unsurprisingly, owner occupiers are four times as likely as renters to under-occupy their homes. One home in three belongs to a debt-free owner-occupier, but this part of the stock houses just one adult in six.  Much of our stock accommodates owners who do not pay the market price for what they consume and lack incentive to ‘downsize.’ Market pressure is displaced onto the young. The political clout of the home-owning majority – and the vested interests that lead opinion – mean the true picture is largely undiscussed. Private landlords, planners and overseas investors become handy scapegoats.

I have no wish to encourage more scapegoating, or inflame inter-generational conflict, or applaud nimbyish hostility to building. We just need an honest discussion about how to rebalance our broken housing market, and what will happen next if we fail. Building is part of the solution, but it will not achieve much unless we use our stock much more efficiently. Since the late nineteen-fifties, governments have treated housing as a tax-sheltered safe haven for personal capital. A solution probably involves shifting taxation onto assets and away from income. The economic answers are not difficult.  Politics is much harder. Until there is a serious attempt to inform electors, the work cannot start.

 

Alumni

  • Hertford today
    • Hertford Virtual Events
      • COVID-19 rapid testing technology
      • Global supply chains after Covid
      • The software that led to the lockdown
      • Risk management during a global pandemic
      • Think and Act Big! How to navigate through the pandemic
    • Introducing Hertford
    • Hertford statistics
    • John Donne Lectures
      • Susie Orbach (2020)
      • Mary Beard (2019)
      • Nick Clegg (2018)
      • Mark Thompson (2017)
      • Frances O’Grady (2016)
      • Shami Chakrabarti (2015)
      • Tony Hall (2014)
      • Gus O’Donnell (2013)
      • Mary Robinson (2012)
      • Toby Barnard (2010)
    • Neil Tanner and the Tanner Scheme
      • The Tanner Scheme
      • Tanner Day
      • Recollections of the Tanner scheme
      • The Tanner Research Project
    • The Simpkin Dynasty
      • Simpkin
      • Simpkins (Simpkin II)
      • Simpkin III
      • Simpkin IV
  • Meet the Hertfordians
    • HertNet
    • HertFolk
    • 50 years of Co-education
    • Our History of Access
  • Publications
    • Hertford College Magazine
    • The Bridge
    • Hertford College Donor Report
    • Hertford College E-News
    • Hertford Blog
      • Photography takes flight
      • Who wants to be a politician?
      • Money, money, money
      • Hertford in the time of Corona
      • A Hertford Chemist in Lockdown
      • New rules – the Corona Sashay
      • EnglishLit to LockdownLit in 2020
      • Lawyer in the Loop
      • Isolation in the face of disease past and present
      • H is for Hawk
      • Floating in Pre-Lockdown Copenhagen
      • Mentoring opens doors to Oxbridge
      • Running to cope with PTSD
      • Challenger banks rally to meet the coronavirus call
      • Being an Olympian with no Olympics
      • The Truth About the Housing Crisis
      • Rethinking Plastics
      • Donating my hair to find a cure
      • Life in the E Fast Lane
      • What can new digital currencies learn from COVID track & trace?
      • Doctors Made Invisible
      • Why I’ll Be Embracing Failure in 2021
      • Pianos for Hertford
      • Reaching out in lockdown
      • Fostering inclusion and diversity
  • Alumni societies
    • The Hertford Society
    • Hertford10
  • Alumni FAQs
  • Update your details
  • Meet the Development team

Study here

  • Undergraduates
  • Graduates
  • Visiting students
  • Outreach with schools and colleges

Living here

  • Where you will live
  • Eating here
  • Library & resources
  • Chapel & Faith
  • Do what you love
  • Help is on hand

Our people

  • Our people

News, events and more

  • Our vision for 2030
  • News
  • Events
  • Hertford history
  • Rare books & Archives
  • International Programmes
  • Conferences & events
  • Governance & legal
  • Vacancies
  • Visit us
  • Contact us

Follow us

Hertford College
Catte Street
Oxford
OX1 3BW


Tel: +44 (0)1865 279 400

© 2025 Hertford College Registered Charity No. 1137527

  • Contact us
  • Privacy
  • Legal

Site by Franks and Franks